Perfect Attendance Awards? Let’s Talk About What Really Deserves Attention

If you saw this Instagram post about replacing perfect attendance awards with kindness awards, you already know where this is headed. The comments section was full of parents and teachers saying the same thing: Why are we still celebrating kids for showing up sick instead of showing up kind?

Remember when schools handed out perfect attendance awards? At the time, it felt like an achievement. Like gold stars for being dependable. Showing up with a tissue in one hand and a cough drop in the other.

But looking back, many of us realize what that message taught: show up no matter what. Sick? Push through. Exhausted? Doesn’t matter. Need a mental break? Too bad. Your value comes from being present, not from how you’re doing.

That’s not resilience…it’s conditioning. And when we praise that in kids, we end up raising adults who answer work emails with a fever, who skip rest because “someone’s counting on me,” who burn out quietly while smiling through it.

Why attendance awards miss the mark

On paper, they sound harmless. A way to encourage consistency. But in practice, the “never miss a day” mindset has ripple effects.

It pressures kids to come in sick (“I don’t want to ruin my streak”), makes parents feel guilty for keeping them home, and unfairly penalizes those who can’t attend every day, like kids with chronic illness, transportation struggles, or family obligations that make attendance complicated.

And here’s something many people don’t realize: for a lot of schools, these awards aren’t just about pride. They’re about funding. In many states, public schools receive money based on attendance numbers. The more “perfect attendance,” the more dollars. That pressure trickles down, even when teachers and administrators wish it didn’t.

So no, attendance itself isn’t the problem. Kids need structure, and schools need consistent participation to teach effectively and stay funded. The problem is what we teach around it. When we glorify presence over health, numbers over well-being, or performance over compassion.

This also ties into extrinsic vs. intrinsic motivation. Rewarding the behavior rather than nurturing the reason behind it. When kids learn to chase recognition (“I have to go or I won’t get the award”) instead of understanding the value of showing up (“I want to learn, be with my friends, and contribute to my class”), it builds compliance, not curiosity. Over time, that focus on external validation can chip away at a child’s internal drive, the very thing we want to strengthen as they grow.

What these awards teach (and why it matters)

When we reward perfect attendance, we teach kids that their worth is tied to showing up, no matter how they feel.

That mindset sticks. It becomes the adult who apologizes for taking a sick day. The employee who works through the flu. The parent who can’t rest without guilt.

And for kids who can’t achieve perfect attendance because of chronic illness or family instability, the message can sting. It can feel like proof they’re already behind, no matter how hard they’re trying.

Finding the balance when attendance still matters

Here’s where nuance matters. Attendance does matter. Kids learn best when they’re consistently engaged, connected, and present. But the path to good attendance isn’t paved with guilt, it’s built with understanding, flexibility, and support.

Some mornings, you know your child can rally with a pep talk and a good breakfast. Other mornings, you can tell they need a day to rest and reset. That’s part of raising emotionally aware, self-regulating kids and helping them listen to their bodies.

And then there’s the other layer: not every parent has the luxury of choice. Many working parents don’t have paid sick leave or backup care. Keeping a child home, even when they’re unwell, can mean lost wages or risking a job. So when we talk about attendance, we can’t ignore privilege.

When schools reward perfect attendance without context, they often end up rewarding stability and access, not effort. That’s why we need policies rooted in empathy and not punishment.

A bigger question about school culture

The attendance conversation taps into something larger: what schools are designed to value, and what that teaches kids long before they reach adulthood.

Our education system was built during the Industrial Revolution, when the goal was to create punctual, obedient, standardized workers. It worked for that era. It lifted literacy and created opportunity. But the world has changed, and the structure of school hasn’t caught up.

Today, we still reward the same traits: compliance, output, and endurance.

Perfect attendance becomes a badge of reliability.
Straight A’s become proof of effort.
Silence and sitting still become signs of respect.

But those aren’t the only skills kids need anymore. When we praise showing up no matter what, following every rule, and keeping up with rigid schedules, we’re unintentionally teaching lessons that carry into adulthood:

• Attendance over well-being → Show up even when you’re unwell.

• Compliance over curiosity → Follow directions instead of asking questions.

• Metrics over meaning → Chase grades and rankings instead of growth.

• Overwork over balance → Equate exhaustion with ambition.

The result? A culture that trains kids to perform rather than to reflect.
To achieve rather than to rest.
To measure their worth by productivity instead of purpose.
And just like in corporate life, that model rewards burnout over balance.

This isn’t on teachers. They’re working inside a system built decades ago and doing their best with limited resources. But it’s a reminder that the system itself needs updating. If we want emotionally healthy, creative, compassionate adults, the lessons we praise in childhood need to change too.

Interested in this conversation? Listen to this PedsDocTalk Podcast episode for more on how school culture shapes kids’ mental health and motivation, and what it might look like to teach for connection, not just compliance.

Healthier ways to encourage attendance

Attendance is important, let’s be clear. Routine and structure help kids thrive. But we can honor that without glorifying perfection or guilt-tripping families. Here are better ways to encourage presence without glorifying burnout:

• Celebrate effort and improvement, not perfection. Instead of “perfect attendance,” try “steady growth” awards. Recognize kids who’ve made progress, like improving from missing 20 days to 10. That shows responsibility and realistic effort.

• Connect attendance to belonging. Small phrases like “We missed your jokes yesterday” or “It’s better when you’re here” remind kids they matter for who they are, not a number on a chart. Belonging motivates more than guilt ever could.

• Partner with families. Sometimes absences are less about motivation and more about logistics or health barriers. Schools that ask, “How can we support you?” build trust instead of resentment. Offering support, like transportation help, flexible make-up work, or communication about chronic illness, encourages attendance in a compassionate way.

• Use small, positive reinforcement. Instead of a big end-of-year award, classrooms can do small recognition moments. A shoutout in a morning meeting or a group goal (like celebrating with an extra recess) can build connection instead of pressure.

• Teach the “why.” Kids are more motivated when they understand the why. Frame it around friendships, learning continuity, and building habits that will help them later, rather than “don’t mess up your perfect record.”

The bigger picture

Attendance will always matter since it’s how kids connect to learning and community. But the way we frame it matters just as much.

Health, rest, and character shouldn’t have to compete with attendance. They should coexist with it. The long-term goal isn’t a row of certificates; it’s a generation of kids who know how to show up for others and for themselves, without sacrificing their well-being.

So instead of perfect attendance awards, let’s aim for a culture that values consistency and compassion. Presence and perspective. Because we don’t just want kids who never miss a day, we want kids who know why they show up when they do.

That’s the kind of presence that truly counts.

On The Podcast

This week, I sit down with two incredible guests to unpack one of the most talked-about (and misunderstood) press conferences in recent months. I’m joined by Dr. Tanya Altmann, pediatrician and founder of Calabasas Pediatrics Wellness Center, and Dr. Anshu Batra, developmental-behavioral pediatrician and autism specialist, to separate fact from fear when it comes to Tylenol, leucovorin, and autism.

We talk about what the latest research actually shows, what parents should know, and why conversations about autism deserve more nuance and empathy than political headlines.

The American school system was built to measure performance but at what cost? In this Follow Up episode, Dr. Mona sits down with Lauren Smith, a former educator and nationally certified school psychologist, to unpack how our current approach to education fuels anxiety, burnout, and perfectionism in kids.

They dive into the ripple effects of over-testing, constant competition, and the push to perform that begins as early as kindergarten. From standardized tests to college rankings, the conversation explores how a culture obsessed with metrics is stealing creativity, rest, and joy from learning — and what real change could look like.

On YouTube

Parents tell me all the time that formula prep feels overwhelming, especially when you’re sleep-deprived and second-guessing every scoop at 3 a.m. In this video, I walk you through how to safely prepare, store, and serve both powdered and ready-to-feed formula so it finally feels simple and stress-free. I’ll also share practical tips on water choices, travel prep, and what really matters for your baby’s safety. This video includes:

• Powder vs. ready-to-feed formula

• How to safely prepare formula

• How to prepare ready-to-feed-formula

• How to make powdered formula

• How to store baby formula

• Traveling with formula

• Formula pro tips

Ask Dr. Mona

An opportunity for YOU to ask Dr. Mona your parenting questions!

Dr. Mona will answer these questions in a future Sunday Morning Q&A email. Chances are if you have a parenting concern or question, another parent can relate. So let's figure this out together!