Toddler Sibling Jealousy and Rivalry

Sibling relationships can be full of love and laughter – until they’re not. One moment, they’re sharing giggles over a silly game, and the next, you’re stepping in to calm the chaos over who gets the blue cup. Whether it’s adjusting to a new sibling or navigating the ever-changing dynamics of sharing space and attention, sibling rivalry is a familiar challenge for parents of toddlers.

Jealousy, arguments, and power struggles are so common in sibling relationships – and not just with toddlers. These moments can come out of nowhere, like when you’re rushing out the door, and suddenly, it’s a battle over who gets their shoes on first. Or they might bubble up during quieter moments, like when one child interrupts while the other is reading to get your attention. It’s all part of them figuring out how to share, express themselves, and build those early relationships with each other.

It’s not always easy, but these sibling interactions aren’t signs of “bad behavior.” Instead, they’re opportunities for your children to learn important skills like sharing, problem-solving, and working as a team. When you understand what’s behind these moments, it’s easier to step in with empathy and help your children build a stronger bond.

Why Jealousy Happens

Sibling jealousy often comes from a mix of emotions and a toddler’s limited ability to process them. To a toddler, sharing attention, toys, and space can feel overwhelming when they’re still learning how to express themselves. Whether they’re adjusting to a new sibling or just figuring out the family dynamic, it’s common for these feelings to bubble up.

Sometimes jealousy shows up as clinginess or regression – asking to be carried more, wanting a pacifier again, or needing extra reassurance. Other times, it’s louder, like tantrums, defiance, or frustration that seems to come out of nowhere. And then there are the subtle moments – interrupting when you’re focused on another child, testing limits, or seeking attention in ways that catch you off guard. These behaviors might feel challenging in the moment, but they’re often a way for your child to say, “I need you.”

It’s not about fixing these moments or trying to make them stop. Instead, it’s about understanding what’s driving them. When you see sibling jealousy as a natural part of your toddler’s development– not a “problem to solve” or a sign you’ve done something wrong– it becomes easier to approach these moments with a sense of empathy and patience.

Building Bonds and Reducing Rivalry

Sibling conflicts are inevitable, but they’re also opportunities to teach your children how to navigate relationships, express themselves, and solve disagreements. While these moments might feel draining at the time, they can be valuable chances to help strengthen their bond over time. Here are some ways to help your children connect while easing the tension:

Celebrate their unique roles

Toddlers thrive on feeling special. Highlight each child’s unique strengths or contributions to the family, whether it’s being the “expert” at puzzles or the “helper” with feeding the baby. This helps them feel valued and reassures them that there’s enough love and attention to go around.

Spend one-on-one time

Even a few minutes of uninterrupted time with each child can go a long way. It might be as simple as reading their favorite book before bed or playing a quick game of “I Spy” on a walk. These moments show them they don’t have to compete for your attention– it’s already there.

Frame siblings as teammates

Help your child see each other as allies, not competitors. Use phrases like, “Your baby sister loves when you make her laugh!” or “Let’s all work together to clean up so we can play a game.” This language encourages teamwork and reinforces the idea that they’re on the same team– they can do things together.

Stay neutral during conflicts

Instead of jumping in as the referee, guide them toward finding solutions. Try saying, “It looks like you both want the same toy. How can we figure this out together?” This approach works best when emotions aren’t too high. But let’s be real – sometimes one (or both!) of your children might already be crying or yelling, and problem-solving feels impossible in the moment. In those cases, it’s okay to pause and focus on calming them down first. You can say, “I see you’re both upset right now. Let’s take a breath, and we’ll figure this out together once we’re calm.” If things are escalating, you may need to separate them for a moment. Removing one child from the situation to help them settle can make a big difference. You can revisit the issue later, once everyone is calmer, to model taking turns or finding a solution together. This not only helps them practice problem-solving but also reinforces that it’s okay to take a break when emotions feel heightened.

Scripts for The Most Common Situations

Even with the best of strategies, sibling conflicts can leave you wondering what to say in the moment. But here’s the thing–sometimes, having a general idea of what to say can help you feel more prepared when the moment presents itself. Here are a few realistic and practical scripts to help you respond when things get tense: 

Respond: “It sounds like you’re upset. Let’s find a safe spot for your special things, and then we can figure out what they can play with.” This approach validates their feelings while offering a solution.

Respond: “I hear you. What is unfair? Maybe we can figure something out together.” Acknowledge their feelings first, then guide them toward understanding that fairness doesn’t always mean equality.

Respond: “It looks like you both want to play with this toy. Let’s figure out if we can play together. Maybe one of you can drive the trash truck while the other loads up the trash.” If emotions are still running high and it’s not working, you might say, “I can see you both feel upset about sharing. Let’s take a break from the trash truck for now and find something else to play with. Once we’re feeling calmer, we can talk about playing with it.” This approach starts by encouraging a collaborative solution but leaves room to step back if things escalate.

Respond: “I hear you need me right now, but I’m listening to [sibling] first. I’ll be right there as soon as I can.”

Key reminders: You don’t need to get it “right” every time. These moments are more about consistency– consistently responding is how they learn. It’s also important to remember that you won’t always need to do this. Over time, with your guidance, they’ll learn to navigate these moments themselves–and you’ll find yourself stepping in less and less.

Final thoughts: Sibling challenges are opportunities

Yes– it’s easy to feel frustrated or overwhelmed when sibling conflicts arise. Whether it’s battles over toys, cries of “That’s not fair!” or constant interruptions, these moments can feel like they’re pulling you in every direction. But, sometimes, it’s helpful to reframe the situation– these challenges are actually opportunities.

Each argument or disagreement is a chance for your children to learn how to share, communicate, and build stronger relationships with each other. They’re figuring out how to navigate a sibling bond–a relationship that’s completely unique. Somehow, siblings can show unconditional love even when their interactions are more intense than those with a friend. And let’s face it, even adults are still working through their sibling relationships!

That doesn’t mean it’s always easy. There will be days when you’re stepping in more than you’d like or when the emotions feel bigger than the solutions. And that’s okay– you don’t need to handle every conflict seamlessly. What matters most is your consistency and that your children see you modeling empathy and patience.

In time, the lessons you’re teaching will stick. They’ll learn to share the toy, work out disagreements, and build a connection that will last a lifetime. And as chaotic as it might feel now, you’re helping to lay the foundation for sibling bond that will grow stronger with time.

For more insights and strategies, check out the PedsDocTalk podcast episode about sibling jealousy. The episode explores how to normalize temperament, foster change when a toddler shows aggression, and support your toddler through feelings of jealousy.

On The Podcast

What does it really mean to parent with data–and how do you do it without losing your mind?

Let’s unpack the power and pitfalls of data-driven parenting in a world full of misinformation and clickbait. If you’ve ever felt overwhelmed by studies, headlines, or trying to “do it right,” this episode will bring clarity, nuance, and a whole lot of reassurance. Today, I’m joined by Emily Oster, an economist and NYT best-selling author to discuss:

• How data can guide parenting decisions–without demanding perfection or causing overwhelm.

• Ways to navigate conflicting research, misinformation, and fear-based headlines in today’s media landscape.

• Practical tips for building data literacy, knowing when to seek evidence, and trusting your instincts as a parent.

On YouTube

Learn how to manage your child’s asthma with expert tips on triggers, inhalers, daily meds, and action plans for better control and peace of mind. This video covers:

• Asthma treatment options

• Environmental strategies to manage asthma

• Short term relief: Rescue inhalers

• Long-term asthma control: Preventative medications

• Why long-term inhaled steroids are better than frequent albuterol use

• Long-Acting Beta-Agonists (LABAs)

• Medication misconceptions and common questions

• The importance of an asthma action plan

• Recognizing an asthma exacerbation

• When to see a specialist for asthma

Ask Dr. Mona

An opportunity for YOU to ask Dr. Mona your parenting questions!

Dr. Mona will answer these questions in a future Sunday Morning Q&A email. Chances are if you have a parenting concern or question, another parent can relate. So let's figure this out together!