Your Child Lied, Now What?

You know the moment. You ask a simple question, “Did you wash your hands?” and your child confidently says yes. Except… you didn’t hear the sink run. And the soap hasn’t moved.

And just like that, you’re standing in the hallway feeling like a detective, or maybe a lawyer, wondering whether to cross-examine your four-year-old.

Lying feels jarring when it first shows up. But here’s the good news: it’s incredibly common, especially after age four, and it usually has more to do with development than deception. In fact, the first time a child lies isn’t a sign of moral failure. It’s a sign that their brain is developing imagination, prediction, and a sense of consequences.

That doesn’t mean we ignore it. But it does mean we can respond with more curiosity and less courtroom energy.

When my own son started lying, it began with handwashing around 4 years of age. He’d say, “I did!” but the sink was dry and the paint was still on his fingers.

It would’ve been easy to slip into cross-examination mode: “Are you sure? Why are your hands still dirty?” But instead of playing detective, I shifted into narrator.

Rather than grilling him for the truth, I described what I saw, like a calm narrator in a documentary: “You’re telling me you washed your hands, but I didn’t hear the water. Can you show me your hands?”

Then I added a gentle observation: “Hmm, they still have some paint on them. Let’s try again. Do you want to go on your own or want me to help?”

Sometimes that was enough. Other times, he’d double down: “No, Mom, I did wash!”

I’d respond without accusation, just steady narration:
“I hear you. And what I’m seeing is that your hands still need a little more washing before we eat. Your food will be ready after that.”

It wasn’t about winning an argument. It was about modeling honesty, keeping the door open, and showing him that telling the truth didn’t have to come with fear. 

Before we get into what to do, it’s important to understand why kids lie. You know I love explaining the “why” behind behavior, because when we understand what’s happening developmentally, we can guide our kids more thoughtfully. Sometimes, we can even appreciate the skill they’re practicing… while still helping them learn to choose honesty.

Why kids lie

Lying often starts showing up after age 3.5 or 4, right around the same time a child’s imagination takes off, their understanding of social rules starts to deepen, and their sense of independence begins to grow. In many ways, lying at this age is less about trying to deceive and more about exploring how the world works.

Here are some of the most common reasons young kids lie:

Imagination and reality start to blur

Children at this age live in a rich, imaginative world. They may say something that sounds untrue, but in their mind, it makes sense. For example, my son once told me his friend left school in an ambulance. I texted her mom, and she hadn’t. Turns out, the friend had a minor injury, and he assumed she went to the hospital because that’s what happens when people get hurt… and that’s where his dad works. It wasn’t a calculated lie. It was a four-year-old connecting dots through imagination and past experience.

Testing boundaries

As kids become more aware of rules and expectations, they start experimenting: What happens if I say this instead of that? Will I still get in trouble? Will Mom believe me? These moments are part of how they learn cause and effect, not necessarily signs that they’re being sneaky. It’s often their way of figuring out how much control they have over a situation and how much you’re paying attention.

Avoiding consequences

Sometimes, lying is a protective reflex. If a child thinks telling the truth will lead to disappointment or a consequence, they may say what they think you want to hear. It’s less about trying to get away with something and more about avoiding a reaction they might not know how to deal with yet.

Trying to gain approval

Kids love making us proud. So if they didn’t actually wash their hands or clean up their toys, they may say they did because they want to be that kid who followed through. These kinds of lies are often motivated by a desire to please, not to mislead.

Copying what they see

Children are keen observers, and they repeat what they witness. If they see older siblings, classmates, or even adults bending the truth (even in small ways), they may mimic that behavior. They don’t always understand the nuance, especially when it comes to things like white lies or jokes that rely on exaggeration.

Covering up embarrassment or insecurity

Lying can sometimes be a way to protect themselves when they’re feeling vulnerable. If they’re embarrassed, unsure, or think they’ll be judged, they may deny what really happened. This is often more about emotional safety than it is about avoiding responsibility.

Still learning what “truth” actually means

Many young children are just beginning to grasp the concept of honesty versus dishonesty. They’re figuring out how to explain things, how to express themselves, and how others respond to what they say. Sometimes they’re not even aware that what they’re saying is false. They’re experimenting with language, logic, and cause and effect.

When we zoom out, it becomes clear: most lying in early childhood is less about manipulation and more about exploration. It’s a developmental stage, not a character flaw. And when we respond with connection and clarity, rather than shame or overreaction, we can help our children build a lifelong understanding of honesty, trust, and integrity.

How to respond without shame or overreacting

Once we understand why kids lie, it’s easier to respond with less frustration and more purpose.

That doesn’t mean we ignore the behavior. Kids still need to learn that honesty matters. But the way we respond can shape whether they feel safe telling the truth next time, or whether they feel the need to hide it.

Here’s how to guide them with honesty, trust, and connection:

Stay calm and avoid the “gotcha” tone

It’s tempting to jump in with, “Did you lie to me?” but that often leads to defensiveness or shame. Instead, try:

A neutral tone makes it easier for kids to be honest, even if they didn’t start there.

Get curious, not confrontational

Instead of accusing, ask open-ended questions that help you understand their thinking:

These kinds of questions take the pressure off and make space for truth without fear.

Reinforce the honesty when it happens

If they come back later and tell you the truth, praise that.

When it comes to building positive behavior in kids, reinforcement matters. If you want to see more honesty, recognize it, especially in those moments when they admit the truth after initially saying something else.

This kind of feedback helps kids internalize that honesty is something valued, not just when it’s easy, but even when it takes courage.

Use language that helps them understand

Young kids may not fully grasp what “lying” means. Instead of labeling, offer gentle explanations:

Model honesty in your everyday life

Kids learn from what they see. If you accidentally give the wrong information and correct yourself, say that out loud. Or if you choose to tell a small white lie, explain why you did it. That helps them understand context, not just rules.

Make truth-telling safe

If kids think telling the truth always leads to punishment, they’ll avoid it. But if they know you’ll listen and help them work through it, they’re more likely to come to you.

That might sound like:

This doesn’t mean there are never consequences, but it means the door stays open for honest conversation.

Going back to my son’s lying story: what made the biggest difference wasn’t a lecture or a consequence. It was consistency, safety, and connection. Over time, the lying faded because he learned that he could trust us. That truth-telling didn’t lead to a blow-up. That even when he fibbed, we’d stay calm, help him course-correct, and remind him that honesty mattered, not because we demanded it, but because we modeled it.

Final thoughts

Lying can feel like a red flag, but it’s often just a reflection of a child’s growing brain, not a sign of bad behavior. When we pause before reacting, lead with curiosity, and create space for honesty, we help our kids feel safe telling the truth, even when it’s uncomfortable.

Whether it’s your child swearing they washed their hands (and the soap dispenser tells a different story), blaming a sibling for something you know they did, or insisting “you said yes” when you definitely didn’t, it’s all part of the same developmental process. The “why” behind the lie might be different each time, but your response can stay consistent: calm, open, and focused on connection over correction.

You don’t need a perfect script. Just a steady, safe environment where honesty is something your child sees modeled, reinforced, and respected, even after a fib.

And if lying becomes a pattern around certain situations, like screen time, messes, or social pressure, it’s worth pausing to ask: What’s underneath this? Are they feeling rushed? Nervous about disappointing you? Unsure how to fix what happened? These are moments where connection, not punishment, makes the biggest impact.

For more real-life examples and practical responses, check out the PedsDocTalk YouTube video on lying. I cover common situations and walk through exactly how to support your child with empathy, structure, and trust, so honesty becomes something they feel good about, not afraid of.

Lying may be part of the early years, but it’s also an opportunity. A chance to build the kind of trust that lasts well beyond childhood.

On The Podcast

Ever felt like you’re running on fumes, snapping at your kids, or just going through the motions of parenting with no joy left in the tank? You’re not broken. You’re burned out.

In this episode, Dr. Flora Sinha joins me to break down what parenting burnout really is from a psychological and physiological perspective and why it’s so common (especially for moms). More importantly, she shares actionable, research-backed strategies to help you move from survival mode to a place of more clarity, connection, and peace.

Returning to work while breastfeeding? You’re not alone, and you don’t have to figure it out on your own either.

In this episode, we break down the essentials of pumping and transitioning back to work with your feeding goals intact. Whether you’re just starting to think about pumping or already mapping out a return-to-work plan, this episode covers what you need to know to make it work at work with less stress and more support.

On YouTube

Confused about what to feed your baby first? Learn the best starter foods, how to prep them, and real-life tips from a pediatrician mom. The video includes:

• Best first foods for baby

• How often to feed baby

• How to prepare foods for baby

• Set realistic expectations

• Common feeding myths to ditch

• Pediatrician mom feeding tips

Ask Dr. Mona

An opportunity for YOU to ask Dr. Mona your parenting questions!

Dr. Mona will answer these questions in a future Sunday Morning Q&A email. Chances are if you have a parenting concern or question, another parent can relate. So let's figure this out together!