❝

My grandson was potty trained (to pee) in a couple days, but still refuses to have a BM almost 6 weeks later. Its gotten so bad he won't even go in a diaper. Not sure why this has occurred but now it's become a serious problem. Is this common? Any advice?

Lesely

Yes, this is very common! It can happen during potty training, even with kids who figure out peeing on the potty almost immediately. Pooping can be a whole different story. Some kids feel nervous about pooping on the toilet, sometimes from the feeling, or if they have a painful poop and they’re afraid to go again. Other times we don’t know exactly what started it.

One thing to watch for is a cycle of holding poop and constipation. When kids hold their poop in, it sits in the colon longer and becomes harder to pass. Then, when they finally do poop, it can hurt, which makes them want to hold it in even more. This cycle can be hard to get out of.

If they’re holding in their poop and going several days without a bowel movement, seem uncomfortable or in pain when they go, it’s a good idea to check in with their pediatrician. Constipation could be playing a role, and they’ll be able to help figure out what’s going on. I also have a guide to constipation in children with a few YouTube videos that explain why it happens, what to look out for, and ways to approach it.

In the meantime, I’d take the pressure off pooping in the potty, while trying to make it feel more comfortable and familiar. Easier said than done, but here are a few things to try:

  • Make potty time fun again: Read books about pooping, have a favorite book ready for when sitting on the potty, or have a stuffed animal to pretend. You can talk casually about pooping so it feels like a regular part of life.

  • Give choices: “Do you want to use the big toilet or the potty chair?” or “Do you want to read a book or have some privacy?” If he’s willing to poop in his diaper for now, that could be okay for now, too.

  • Encourage and focus on effort rather than just pooping in the toilet: “You can try and even if nothing comes out, that’s okay!” If they sit great, but avoid the pressure.

  • Keep it positive and reassuring: “Pooping feels a little tricky right now. We can figure it out together.” When he does poop, “There you go! Your body let the poop out!”

If he needs a break from pooping on the potty altogether, that’s okay too. Sometimes kids need a reset, and we want him to feel comfortable letting his poop out, even if that means using a diaper for a while.

It can be frustrating when peeing on the toilet clicked right away, and pooping has become a struggle. Keep giving opportunities, celebrate the effort, and take his lead when he’s not ready. With time and less pressure, he may start to feel more comfortable pooping on the toilet.

For more on this, you can start with listening to my podcast episode, “Everybody Poops! Potty Training Basics,” where we talk about why some kids are afraid to poop on the potty, stool withholding, and ways to help kids feel more comfortable with the process. If you’d like more step-by-step guidance, my No-Pressure Potty Training Course includes how to approach potty training and work through challenges along the way.

The book recommendations above include affiliate links, which means I may earn a small commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

❝

I have a 3 year old that challenges my every “no” and does exactly what I told him not to. How do I respond? I’ve found myself threatening to ground him, but I’m not even sure I want to do that and the only thing that seems to work is threatening to leave (the room, the car…) but that’s something I’d love to be able to just stop saying. What other resources can I use?

Teresa

Oooh 3-year-olds can really test our patience with this. At this age, kids are becoming more independent, they want to have a say in what happens, and they’re discovering just how much control they have. So when you say no and he does the exact opposite, he may be testing what happens when he pushes that limit. His impulse control is also still developing, which means he might know what to do or not to do, but he still has a hard time following in the moment.

My favorite way to think about this is we want him to know you’re going to hold the boundary, even when he’s upset or pushing against it. So what does this look like?

  • Tell him what you want him to do. This is a big one! Instead of saying, “No jumping on the couch!” try, “The couch is for resting, you can jump like a kangaroo on the rug!” 3-year-olds tend to respond better to what they can do with clear direction, rather than only what they can’t do. Who knew parenting a 3-year-old would involve so much marketing? Sometimes, it’s all about how you sell the idea.

  • Offer simple choices when you can. This can help with giving him a sense of control. If it’s time to leave, he still has to go, but he can make a decision about how, maybe hopping like a bunny or holding your hand.

  • Say it, then follow through. This is key! For example, if you’ve told him not to throw a toy and he throws it again, you can say, “I won’t let you throw toys. I’m putting it away for now.” Then put it away.

  • Notice when he does listen. This is so important to change behavior! It’s easy for all the challenging moments to fill up your attention. But when he does follow a direction, even if it’s small, acknowledge it. It helps him understand the behaviors you want to see.

When he gets upset about the boundary, and he might, you can acknowledge that while still holding the limit. “I know you want to keep playing, but it’s time to go. You can walk to the car or I can help you.” Holding boundaries is loving too. The limits still matter even when he’s upset about them. You’re helping him to trust what you say.

I also have a quick video on setting boundaries without always saying no, where I share ways to give kids clear directions, reduce power struggles, and encourage the behaviors you want to see more of.

Instagram post

Ask Dr. Mona

Ask Dr. Mona all your parenting questions!

Dr. Mona will answer these questions in a future Sunday Morning Q&A email. Chances are if you have a parenting concern or question, another parent can relate. So let's figure this out together!

Dr. Mona. Amin

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Keep Reading